Is the West fed up with Canada? What a new survey shows about the federation’s growing fault lines

5c008f1da36316620b196f0cc058dc9b

L'Ouest canadien en pleine rébellion contre Ottawa : la grogne est extrêmement forte en Alberta et en Saskatchewan

Western rage at the “Laurentian elite” is hardly new, either. It flared up most famously as a result of Pierre Trudeau’s National Energy Program in the early 1980s.


But the stubbornness of provincial discontent shouldn’t take away from the serious escalation of ill feeling in Alberta and Saskatchewan that this polling reveals, said Andrew Parkin, director of the Mowat Centre, an Ontario think tank that helped produce the survey along with a handful of other research organizations. (The group used questions that have been asked in national surveys dating back to the 1980s to track opinion over time.)


“There’s a risk there of going, ‘The provinces always want more money, always want more power, and this is just complaining,’ ” he said. “Yes, but it is accentuated at certain places and certain times.”


Now is one of those times.


The federal government’s inability to win approval for major pipelines and its law taxing carbon emissions during a downturn in the domestic oil industry appear to have angered Saskatchewan and Alberta more than at any time in over a generation.


Fifty-seven per cent of residents in both provinces now say the federal government has become personally irrelevant to them. And for the first time since pollsters have been asking the question – as far back as 1987 – majorities in Alberta and Saskatchewan now agree with the statement, “Western Canada gets so few benefits from being part of Canada that they might as well go it on their own.”


Percentage who strongly or somewhat agree with "Western Canada gets so few benefits that it may as well go it on its own"


By province, 1987–2019


 B.C.


 Alta.


 Sask.


 Man.


102030405060%1987198919901992199419972000201020194736__undefined____undefined__


THE GLOBE AND MAIL, SOURCE: ENVIRONICS INSTITUTE


DATA


SHARE


×











































































Region B.C. Alta. Sask. Man.
1987-01-01 47 36    
1989-01-01 39 32 30 30
1990-01-01 35 49 37 32
1992-01-01 45 42 26 47
1994-01-01 32 35 31 30
1997-01-01 36 36 26 26
2000-01-01 35 37 41 31
2010-01-01 36 28 28 19
2019-01-01 44 56 53 35

PERCENTAGE WHO STRONGLY OR SOMEWHAT AGREE WITH "WESTERN CANADA GETS SO FEW BENEFITS THAT IT MAY AS WELL GO IT ON ITS OWN"


Percentage who say "the federal government has become virtually irrelevant to me"


By region, 1998–2019


 1998


 1999


 2000


 2003


 2019


0510152025303540455055CanadaAtlanticQuebecOntarioWestNorth3635293442


THE GLOBE AND MAIL, SOURCE: ENVIRONICS INSTITUTE


DATA


SHARE


×





























































Region 1998 1999 2000 2003 2019
Canada 36 35 29 34 42
Atlantic 40 34 32 33 43
Quebec 35 34 28 32 35
Ontario 38 34 31 31 38
West 32 34 28 38 49
North       40 53

PERCENTAGE WHO SAY "THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT HAS BECOME VIRTUALLY IRRELEVANT TO ME"


“Every survey that’s ever been done about federalism has had most of the provinces outside of Ontario express some measure of discontent,” Mr. Parkin said. Still, “to not notice that alienation is higher than when Preston Manning first came on the scene, and to miss that concern about the future of the French language is stronger in Quebec than when Lucien Bouchard was premier, is to risk missing something fundamental about how the country is working.”


Nowhere is the national angst about Confederation more acute than in Alberta, where fully 71 per cent of residents feel their province doesn’t get the respect it deserves. That is partly due to a sputtering oil sector and anemic economy that have produced high unemployment and swelling public debt, said Colleen Collins, vice-president of the Canada West Foundation, which collaborated on the study.


But the anger also draws on more emotional, symbolic sources. Ms. Collins pointed to remarks by Quebec Premier François Legault dismissing the prospect of a pipeline carrying Alberta’s “dirty energy” through his province, which riled many in the oil patch.


“For one of our own to say, ‘We don’t want your dirty oil’ – that really hurts,” she said. “That felt like a kick in the gut.


“We know we’re blessed and we’re more than happy to share, but it comes down to that question of respect.”


Laurentian Consensus at the centre of Trudeau’s missteps in the SNC-Lavalin affair


Alberta’s oil woes have fuelled lamentable rhetoric across Canada and within the province


Opinion: As Trudeau courts Quebec, the alienation of the West only deepens



State of the federation: Key takeaways from the survey



Is your province/territory treated with the respect it deserves?


2019


No


Yes


Cannot say


Alta.


N.L.


NWT


Sask.


N.S.


Que.


N.B.


Man.


Nunavut


B.C.


PEI


Ont.


Yukon


Canada


0


10


20


30


40


50


60


70


80%


THE GLOBE AND MAIL, SOURCE: ENVIRONICS INSTITUTE



How much influence does your province/territory have on


important national decisions?


2019


Less than its fair share


About its fair share


More than its fair share


Cannot say


N.L.


N.S.


Alta.


Sask.


N.B.


Man.


NWT


Que.


Yukon


B.C.


PEI


Nunavut


Ont.


Canada


0


10


20


30


40


50


60


70


80%


THE GLOBE AND MAIL, SOURCE: ENVIRONICS INSTITUTE